Portrait of Johann Mattheson. Public domain, Wikimedia Commons.
Hamburg, 1713. Johann Mattheson, who signs himself “Secr.” on the title page because by trade he is secretary to the English ambassador, sends to press Das neu-eröffnete Orchestre, a manual for the gentleman who wants to talk about music without cutting a poor figure. Amid the definitions there is a catalogue of seventeen keys, each with its own character. C major, he writes, “hat eine ziemliche rude und freche Eigenschafft”: it has a rather rough and impudent nature, suited to festivities. Some twenty years earlier, in France, Marc-Antoine Charpentier had called it cheerful and warlike. Neither of them devotes a line to D-flat major.
Seventy years later Christian Friedrich Daniel Schubart takes care of it. He writes his Ideen zu einer Ästhetik der Tonkunst between 1784 and 1785, during the ten years of imprisonment that began in 1777; the book will appear posthumously in Vienna in 1806. C major, for him, “ist ganz rein”, is perfectly pure, and its character is innocence, simplicity, naivety, the language of children. D-flat major, instead, is “ein schielender Ton”, a squinting key, which degenerates into grief and delight: it cannot laugh, but it can smile; it cannot howl in weeping, at most it can grimace it.
One could file it all away as literature. On today’s piano D-flat major is C major shifted by one key, identical in every proportion, and Melos has already recounted the price of equal temperament. But the keyboard of Mattheson and Schubart was not tuned that way. In 1691 Andreas Werckmeister, organist of the collegiate church of St Servatius at Quedlinburg, publishes the Musicalische Temperatur. The problem is ancient: twelve pure fifths do not close the circle, they overshoot by a small gap, the Pythagorean comma, and that gap has to be hidden somewhere. The temperament we today call Werckmeister III divides it in four: it narrows by a quarter of a comma the fifths C–G, G–D, D–A and B–F-sharp, and leaves the other eight pure.
The result can be read in the major thirds, the interval that decides the colour of a chord. The pure third, the one nature puts inside every vibrating string, measures 386 cents. In Werckmeister, C–E measures 390: four cents too much, a mistuning you can barely hear. D-flat–F measures 408, the old Pythagorean third, twenty-two cents above the pure; the same goes for F-sharp–A-sharp and A-flat–C. On the modern piano all the thirds measure 400, fourteen cents above the pure, without exception.
The cent is a laboratory unit. The ear hears beats, the pulsation that arises when two almost consonant sounds rub against each other. With A at 440, which was not the pitch of the day but makes the sums comparable, a tuner knows that C–E in the middle of the keyboard must beat around ten times a second. In Werckmeister the same third beats three or four times: a slow undulation, almost a breath. D-flat–F, calculated on the frequencies of the same temperament, beats about seventeen times a second. It is no longer an undulation, it is a buzz, a grain you hear without looking for it. On the piano the two thirds beat more or less in the same way, ten and eleven times, and between the two keys only the difference in pitch remains.
Nobody can prove that Schubart had a Werckmeister in mind when he called D-flat squinting: dozens of circulating temperaments were being proposed, and every tuner had his habits. But the structure was almost always the same, narrow thirds near C and wide thirds toward the keys full of accidentals. The quiet, innocent C major, the D-flat major that cannot quite laugh, have a correlate that can be measured. When in 1722 Bach collected in the first book of the Well-Tempered Clavier a prelude and fugue for each of the twenty-four keys, the third of them he wrote in C-sharp major, seven sharps in the key signature, and not in D-flat.
In London, in 1844, Alfred James Hipkins, who four years earlier had joined the Broadwood piano factory as an apprentice, noticed that the firm’s tuners could not detach themselves from a variety of meantone temperament. In 1846 Walter Broadwood entrusted him with the task of teaching everyone equal temperament.
Hanno scritto per Melos
Antida Carelli · Lorenza Civitareale · Eleonora Colombo · Giada De Sio · Luisa De Vita · Maria Grazia Drago · Samuele Guerzoni · Mariapia Mancini
Melos si scrive in tanti. Proponi un articolo.
