Johann Sebastian Bach, Fugue in B minor BWV 869, autograph of the first book of The Well-Tempered Clavier, 1722. Via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).
Vienna, 10 April 1782. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, twenty-six, writes to his father in Salzburg that every Sunday he goes to Baron Gottfried van Swieten’s, and that there nothing is played but Handel and Bach. He adds that he is putting together a collection of Bach fugues. Ten days later he writes to his sister, and explains something that no counterpoint manual says so clearly: a fugue must not be played too fast, because otherwise the ear cannot tell the subject when it enters, and the effect is lost altogether.
In that sentence there is already half a method of listening. The other half Mozart put into score in the same year. Van Swieten let him take Bach’s scores home, and from the second book of the Well-Tempered Clavier Mozart took five fugues, beginning with the one in C minor, and rewrote them for string quartet. The Köchel catalogue lists them as K. 405. He did not rework them, he barely retouched them. He did something simpler and more revealing: he gave each voice an instrument.
The problem he solved is that of anyone who listens to a four-voice fugue at the piano. There are four voices, but one timbre. The soprano, the alto, the tenor and the bass all come out of the same wood and the same strings, and the ear, to separate them, has only register and rhythm at its disposal. The very names betray the origin: they are called voices because the fugue descends from part-singing, where every line came out of a different throat. The keyboard took away the throats and left the lines. As long as the voices stay far apart it works. When the alto descends and the tenor rises, when two lines cross or run for a stretch a third apart, the texture clots and one can no longer tell who is saying what. With strings this does not happen. The first violin has an edge that the second does not, the viola has a darker veil, the cello speaks from the chest. Even when two voices cross, the colours stay distinct, and the ear follows the colour without effort.
From this comes the exercise, which can be done in an evening with two recordings. One begins with Mozart’s version for quartet, and listens to it at least twice, giving each instrument a name and a character: who starts, who answers, who comes in last and changes the weight of the room. The cello, when it carries the subject, is recognised at once; the viola is the hardest to follow, and it is precisely the one to learn. Then one passes to the same fugue played on the piano or the harpsichord. A curious thing happens. The ear remembers the colours and projects them onto the keyboard: that middle voice which was an indistinct grey now has the timbre of the viola, even though no viola is playing. The four voices are not held in the head by force of concentration. They are held in the head because each has become someone.
The advice in the letter to his sister applies to the second part of the experiment. Among the many recordings of a fugue it is worth choosing one of the slowest, at least the first few times. At a broad tempo every entry of the subject has room to make itself recognised, and the ear has time to ask in which voice it arrived before another arrives. In the C minor fugue the question becomes a game, because the subject also returns inverted and, in the bass, with its notes lengthened, as if the lowest voice were pronouncing it in slow motion.
On 31 December 1782, in Vienna, Mozart dated in his own hand the first of the six quartets he would dedicate to Haydn, the one in G major, K. 387. The finale opens with a subject of four long notes that passes from one instrument to another, in the manner of a fugue.
Hanno scritto per Melos
Antida Carelli · Lorenza Civitareale · Eleonora Colombo · Giada De Sio · Luisa De Vita · Maria Grazia Drago · Samuele Guerzoni · Mariapia Mancini
Melos si scrive in tanti. Proponi un articolo.
