In early June 2023 Stéphane Lissner ceased to be superintendent of the Teatro di San Carlo without anyone having dismissed him. A rule had dismissed him: article 2 of decree-law no. 51 of 10 May 2023, which removed from office the superintendents of the opera and symphony foundations who had reached the age of seventy, whatever the expiry date of their contracts. Lissner had turned seventy in January. In the summer the ministry appointed in his place Carlo Fuortes, who in May had left the helm of RAI. On 12 September the labour court of Naples ordered Lissner’s reinstatement. On 25 July 2024 the Constitutional Court, in ruling no. 146, declared the rule unconstitutional, finding that it bore no relation to the efficiency of the foundations it claimed to safeguard.
The affair is remembered as a palace quarrel. Reread from a distance, it is a lesson in anatomy, because it shows precisely where the power to decide what is sung in Naples resides. Large-scale Italian opera passes through fourteen opera and symphony foundations, from La Scala to the Teatro Massimo in Palermo, from La Fenice to Santa Cecilia. Their architecture, touched up in 2013, has four bodies. The president is the mayor of the city. The governing board, seven people at most, represents the public members and the private ones who contribute at least five per cent of the State grant. The board of auditors watches the accounts. Then there is the superintendent, whom the law calls the sole managing body: he is proposed by the governing board and appointed by the Minister of Culture.
The season is born there. The superintendent may be assisted by an artistic director, whom he chooses himself, and with him he builds the season, which the board approves within the limits of the budget. In Naples Lissner held both posts, superintendent and artistic director. By removing him, the decree removed at a stroke the taste that had written the San Carlo’s latest seasons.
La Scala shows the same chain in calm conditions. On 16 April 2024 the theatre’s board chose Fortunato Ortombina, then superintendent of La Fenice, as successor to Dominique Meyer; the newspapers described it as a compromise between the mayor, Giuseppe Sala, and the minister, Gennaro Sangiuliano. On 12 May 2025 Ortombina brought to the board the name of the new music director, Myung-Whun Chung, in post from 1 January 2027 to 2030, and the board approved it. That day Ortombina explained that he had not chosen according to his personal tastes. It is an honest clarification, and it describes the system better than an organisation chart does. Personal tastes do not disappear: they change hands, from the minister and the mayor to the superintendent, from the superintendent to the conductor, from the conductor to the playbill.
At no point in this chain do the audience, the orchestral players or the critics appear. This is not necessarily a bad thing: a theatre that lives on public money must have someone answerable for it, and that someone has to be appointed. The Italian peculiarity lies elsewhere. The chain is short, its first link is political, and the time of politics does not coincide with that of the theatre. Chung was chosen almost twenty months before the start of his mandate, because singers and conductors are booked years in advance. A government, on the other hand, can cut a mandate short with an emergency decree, and it takes fourteen months and a ruling of the Constitutional Court to say that it could not.
Anyone who wants to know why a season contains certain titles and not others must therefore climb the chain to the very top, where there is no musician. On 7 December Myung-Whun Chung will open La Scala’s season with Otello, and from 1 January 2027 he will be its music director. A superintendent chose him, and that superintendent was, by law, appointed by a minister.
Hanno scritto per Melos
Antida Carelli · Lorenza Civitareale · Eleonora Colombo · Giada De Sio · Luisa De Vita · Maria Grazia Drago · Samuele Guerzoni · Mariapia Mancini
Melos si scrive in tanti. Proponi un articolo.
