Enrico Melozzi
0%

Pompeo Batoni, Emperor Joseph II with Grand Duke Pietro Leopoldo of Tuscany, 1769. Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna, via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).

Vienna, Burgtheater, 1 May 1786. The Marriage of Figaro is staged for the first time, and Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart conducts from the keyboard, as was the custom. The audience does not wait for the end to give its verdict: it applauds, calls, insists on hearing things again. Some numbers are repeated that same evening, and at the following performances the requests do not diminish. The show grows longer. In Vienna the success of an opera has a precise measure: how many times the house forces the singers to start over.

At that point the emperor steps in. Joseph II, who answered personally for the Burgtheater, writes to his superintendent, Count Orsini-Rosenberg, a note worth reading for what it concedes even before what it forbids. To prevent operas from running too long, he says in essence, and without depriving the singers of the glory they seek in the repetition of their pieces, it seems reasonable to him to give the public notice: no piece for more than one voice will be repeated. From that month, in Vienna, duets, trios and ensemble pieces are no longer encored. Arias are.

When someone finally put the encore in writing, it was to contain it, and to contain it he had to recognise it. Joseph II’s note shows that the encore was already a pact, with two parties and one object: the public pays with applause, the singer repays with repetition, and neither can withdraw completely without offending the other. The sovereign does not abolish the pact. He regulates it, and leaves it in the hands of the solo singer, the one who stands in front of the house with no one beside them.

A little more than a century later, at La Scala, Arturo Toscanini abolished it altogether, along with the lights left on in the hall and the ladies’ hats. This magazine has already written that each of those rules was right and that together they turned the theatre into a museum display case. The encore was the most delicate to remove, because it was the only point of the performance at which the house decided something. The programme is chosen by the theatre, the cast is chosen by the theatre, the cuts and the reprises are chosen by the conductor. The encore is chosen by whoever bought the ticket, aloud, in that moment, and all that is left to the artist is the freedom to accept or refuse. To defend it does not mean to regret the rowdy evenings of the nineteenth century: it is enough to leave, inside the ritual, a door that the audience can push.

In recitals the contract is still fully in force, and whoever frequents concert halls knows its clauses without ever having read them. The encore is not announced on the poster, it is granted. It is asked for with applause that does not stop, and it is not demanded. It lasts less than what came before, and usually weighs less. The first is almost due, the third is a gift, the fifth a small event. Refusing is possible, but it costs: a house that applauds for a long time and sees the lights come back on leaves with the impression of an unpaid debt.

At the opera the contract remains suspended, and every now and then someone puts it back in force. On 20 February 2007, at the premiere of Donizetti’s La fille du régiment at La Scala, Juan Diego Flórez finished Ah! mes amis, the aria of the high Cs, under an ovation that would not subside, and sang it again. There had been no encore like it at La Scala for over seventy years. The house had asked, the singer had accepted, and the pact had renewed itself, as if the ban had never existed.

Fourteen months later, on 21 April 2008, Flórez did the same at the Metropolitan Opera in New York. It was the first solo encore granted on that stage since 1994.

Il testo è delIl Coro di Melos di Melos

Hanno scritto per Melos

Antida Carelli · Lorenza Civitareale · Eleonora Colombo · Giada De Sio · Luisa De Vita · Maria Grazia Drago · Samuele Guerzoni · Mariapia Mancini

Melos si scrive in tanti. Proponi un articolo.

♪ Ascolta la mia musica
🇬🇧 EN ▾